Dáil Privilege and Publication – You Can Publish and not be Damned

Dáil Privilege and Publication | Constitution Project @ UCC.

Really interesting piece by a noted constitutional lawyer. Can the media publish the Dail proceedings with the allegations of Catherine Murphy TD? Probably.. see below

The most relevant Article of the Constitution here is 15.12. Article 15.13 has important protections for the TDs and Senators themselves but does not directly concern the media. Article 15.12 however tells us that “all official reports and publications of the Oireachtas…and utterances made in either House wherever published shall be privileged”.

The exact meaning of privilege and the extent of this protection in this situation is uncertain as we have never had a case exactly on point however the Supreme Court did rule in Attorney General v Hamilton (No 2) in 1993 that this privilege was wide ranging and extends “to any form of legal proceedings” and is not merely confined to defamation.

The Irish text of the Constitution (which is the authoritative text) makes this somewhat clearer whereby the Irish text says “táid saor ar chúrsaí dlí cibé áit a bhfoilsítear” which translates literally as “being free from matters of law wherever published” which would seem to suggest that publication of official records is absolutely covered and extents to all forms of legal actions including contempt of Court.

A further question arises as to whether the protection granted by Article 15.12 merely extends to official publications which are published by the Oireachtas itself or whether others who publish the materials are also covered. The law in the area of defamation defines publishing very broadly as bringing material to the attention of another and it is difficult to see any Court willing to define publication in this context so narrowly as to only cover documents published directly by the Oireachtas themselves.

On balance it would appear that publication of comments made in the Dáil should enjoy the protection of privilege particularly with a view to the seemingly wider scope offered by the Irish text of Article 15.12 however questions still arise as to the limits of this privilege. Could TDs, for example, constantly frustrate all publication based injunctions simply by making statements in the Dáil which could then be reported? This would bring us to the point where the Court’s Order would essentially become irrelevant and worthless and then questions would naturally arise as to what extent Courts should continue to allow privilege to reach.

1 thought on “Dáil Privilege and Publication – You Can Publish and not be Damned

  1. Pingback: The Silence of the Media Lambs | Brian M. Lucey

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s