So the Bauld Melanie, she who believes Ireland has only a tenuous claim to nationhood has waded in again. With the ludicrous suggestion from Ray Basset yesterday that we should leave the EU and cleave to Mother England, she now suggests Irexit as a way forward. It is indeed as she states a no-brainer.
Below the fold, a fisking, her words in Italics…
The Republic of Ireland
Name of the country is not the Republic of Ireland Melanie. When your trying to persuade us, try to get the name right. Article 4 of our constitution gives the name. Ireland
is intimately intertwined economically,
but much much less so since, lets see, what happened in 1973 and then in 1992…
yes, thank you Strongbow, Laudibater and all that…
well, I give you that
and culturally with the UK.
Brexit, which the Irish government never saw coming,
Really? That explains why we have hundreds of pages of documents and thousands of hours of diplomacy which was MIRACULOUSLY sprung into action the day after the Brexit vote
therefore has huge implications for Ireland – for the worse as long as Ireland itself remains in the EU.
No, Mel, we will take a hit ANYHOW. Thanks for that – John Bruton, known in some circles here as John Unionist so pro british was he seen in his leadership, what he called “an unfriendly act“. So, having decided to huff off, which will cause some but not overwhelming damage with GDP levels Brexit +5 at 3.5% lower than otherwise , you now suggest what..?
Ireland once got more out of the EU than it paid in. That ratio has now been reversed: it is now a net contributor.
Yes, its called “success”. A large part of the impetus to the Economic Union, still incomplete, is convergence. We made a success out of our membership and now are happy to help. There is ZERO commentary here beyond the lunatic fringe that we are being screwed by the EU. Zero.
Once Britain exits the EU, Ireland will urgently need a free-trade deal with the UK, its main trading partner,
BZZ: Wrong. Main trading partner is the EU, excluding UK. Try to get the facts right Melanie.
as well as the continued free movement of peoples between Ireland and the UK.
CTA is independent of the EU and has been agreed so by all.
These arrangements are essential to avoid otherwise certain and large-scale damage to the Irish economy.
GDP levels under the hardest brexit are estimated to be 3.5% lower five years after Brexit. Thats not peanuts but its not “large scale”.
They cannot be achieved once the UK exits the EU if Ireland remains signed up to it.
Something which is not going to happen is not something to avoid.
As the former Irish diplomat Ray Bassett argues in this pamphlet “Irexit”, or Ireland leaving the EU, would benefit Ireland’s economy; would enable it to put Irish interests first rather than continuing to subjugate them to the interests of the EU; and would obviate the threat of a post-Brexit “hard border” with Northern Ireland, preserving instead the hard-won “peace process” status quo in relations with the province.
It might be worth reading the reams of thorough , comprehensive, and laughter filled takedowns of Ray Bassets screed. If you want, I will be doing a piece in the Irish Examiner on the weekend in my column, so stay tuned
What’s not to like?