On Burning Bondholders and Constitutional Politics

So : we know now that Ireland was indeed threatened. But a bigger issue seems to lurk , but this may be just my ignorance

In late march 2011 the newly elected Minister for Finance went into the Dail to outline what the government would do regarding banks and bonds. There was no mention of enforcing losses on senior unsecured bondholders. And so about 8b more debt than was needed was loaded onto the Irish taxpayer. Thats about 400m a year in interest.

This is despite a government, meaning cabinet decision having been made, presumably on the regular meeting 2 days before, or an earlier one, that such would be done. Testimony from the minister suggests that literally as he was about to deliver the speech he got a phone call from the ECB which was in effect a direct interference in the cabinet decision.  JC Trichet told him, bluntly, not to announce the cabinet decision.

The nature and likelihood of the realism of the threats can be discussed in another post. But some questions arise.

  • Who told Trichet the cabinet decision? When? Are cabinet decisions not confidential until announced?
  • Noonan said he conferred with the Taoiseach and they, not the cabinet, agreed to drop the burden sharing decision. On what authority was that, as they are not the cabinet?
  • How did Trichet know just when to ring? He gave Noonan no time, and presented him with an almost impossible dilemma. Noonan blinked. And 8b was lost
  • Was the decision by Trichet his alone or made by the ECB?  If so where and when? Why was the Governor of the Central Bank not called to quiz that decision making?
  • How realistic was the threat that “an economic bomb would go off” ? Thats for another day but the decision made cost 8b. Would the incremental damage of this putative bomb have been 8b? Noonan thought so. On what basis was that decision made?

1 thought on “On Burning Bondholders and Constitutional Politics

  1. Breda Cahill, Wexford.

    This is just further, damning proof that the people of Ireland and our welfare was never represented in any way when it came to the bank bail-out and the decision not to burn the bondholders. We had no leaders who said “stop!”….this will destroy the quality of life for generations of Irish people!
    Proper constitutional procedures were not followed, the authority of the cabinet as a whole was not considered and the public representatives elected by the people of Ireland, from every county in Ireland, were not even allowed a say….isn’t that just the most abject failure of Government
    and the democratic process that we are supposed to be vested in?
    And now these “leaders” who have utterly failed the Irish people want to
    buy our votes with a soft budget…when what they should be doing is apologizing for all the mistakes they have made, fixing all the things that have been done wrong with our economy and re-negotiating our debt
    deal with The Troika and the IMF!
    For God’s sake, Ireland, and for your children’s future, please clean house and elect candidates to Dail Eireann who are capable of running this country well and who will not put their re-election prospects ahead of what is right for the Irish people and our innate right to a decent quality of life!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s